The story starts off as a daydream of Draculaura at her Sweet 1600 party in the catacombs, which Cleo and Cawdeen agree to make happen. Frankie then explains that Draculaura's birthday was in a few days and Clawd attempts to get Draculaura a gift but ends up getting scolded by Clawdeen. Which eventually leads to him asking C.A. Cupid for help, but it doesn't turn out well when he builds her a stepstool to reach things in her locker, which makes Draculaura think that Clawd thinks she's short. Draculaura soon reveals she used to date a boy named Valentine but she had to move away from him.